TEP


The
Editing
Pencil
Confused about an editor's tasks versus a proofreader's tasks? Check out the explanation below.
The
Editing
Pencil
Do you know what kind of editing or proofreading you need? I've described below some the kinds of services editors and proofreaders provide.
Editors
-
A developmental editor helps the author in developing and writing the content, determining how to present it, and identifying what kinds of documentation and/or permissions may be necessary for publication. The developmental editor also advises the author regarding rewriting specific sections or reorganizing the text.
​ -
The substantive editor reviews the manuscript’s organizational structure and presentation. In-house editors, the author’s colleagues and/or peers may also handle this type of editing and review process. Sometimes, the same person may provide both developmental and substantive editing.
-
The copy editor’s job (sometimes called the line editor) begins after the manuscript is finished and has been through the reviewing process. A copy editor handles the mechanics of editing: grammar, spelling, punctuation, and the use of a consistent style. The copy editor checks that all proper nouns are spelled consistently throughout the document, identifies and queries biased language, determines whether the author needs to define any unusual terms or acronyms, ensures that all dashes and hyphens are used correctly and that all figures and tables are included and formatted consistently. Depending on the project, the copy editor may also perform other services such as formatting, verifying references and URLs, and/or fact checking.
Proofreaders
-
The proofreader is the final set of eyes before the document is prepared for publication. Once the editor(s) and author(s) are satisfied with the final document, the proofreader ensures that all the revisions have been done, are correct, and that no additional errors have been introduced into the text. The proofreader reviews the hyphenation at the ends of lines, checks for missed spelling errors, verifies the consistent use of typeface and font, and ensures the correct locations of tables and illustrations, paragraph spacing, text alignment, etc.